Young Critics On The Edge- Panel Discussion – Full Audio


Young Critics On The Edge Panel Discussion Photo Credit: Alan King 

On Thursday July 7th, twelve Young Critics from all across the UK and Ireland met for the final time as part of Young Critics On The Edge.

During this session the Young Critics presented their findings to an audience of Symposium Delegates at BCU Birmingham. Here they discussed their process over the previous four days. They also provided critical responses to the four performances they attended as part of Young Critics On The Edge.

The session was chaired by Anna Galligan from Barnstorm Theatre Company with technical support by Alan King of the National Association for Youth Drama (Ireland)

You can listen to the Full Edited recording of the session here

Or you can listen to the session in smaller sections here
































A big thank you to all the On The Edge Festival staff for all their kindness and goodwill over the five days in Birmingham.


Young Critics On The Edge  is a collaboration between Barnstorm Theatre Company,NAYD (National Association for Youth Drama) Ireland and Mess Up The Mess, Get the Chance (Wales) in conjunction with the Symposium strand of theASSITEJ Artistic Gathering for 2016.



Brush – A Review by Saoirse Anton, Young Critic On The Edge


Brush Theatre Company

Birmingham Mac

On The Edge Festival


Hailing from South Korea, Brush tells the story of a young boy who, wishing for a younger brother, embarks on a journey to find magic dust that will make his mother have another child.

This production introduces an interesting and largely effective technique of building the settings and scenarios within the piece by gradually creating paintings on large boards at the back of the stage. With sneezing deities and cosily lit up houses, these paintings are a dynamic and impressive addition to the production. However, such visual delights are not enough to sustain a production on their own.


Brush presented by Brush Theatre Company South Korea


Successful audience interaction takes a balancing act of control and flexibility. Throughout the production, the interactions between performers and audience lacked this balance; too often it felt that the performers were talking at rather than to the audience, breaking the fourth wall but leaving the remains just a little too high to get past.

Though Brush is a mixed bag in terms of technique, it is the plot that is the real stumbling block in this production. It may be poorly articulated at times, but the plot presents the audience with a strong message that must be considered when choosing to see this production. The boy wants a brother, and so does his father, but his mother asserts that she does not want to and cannot have another child because she doesn’t have enough money. Though the show does try to teach good lessons about being a sibling, in the end the boy gets the magic dust to make his mother have another child, he gets his way despite his mother’s wishes. This show is aimed at an audience of 4+, an impressionable demographic. Lessons on ideas such as respect and consent are learned early, and such a strong message in a work can influence that (whether it was intentionally presented or it came as a result of one of numerous gaps in the story-telling within this production.)

Brush Theatre company bring to the stage a production that, while it has artistic potential, misses its mark overall and loses its audience frequently. Overall Brush is a visually creative and interesting production that lacks the support of a confidently developed and delivered script.

Brush finished its run at On The Edge on Tuesday July 5th.

Come join Young Critics On The Edge at Birmingham Repertory Theatre on July 7th  in the Parkside Building, Lecture Theatre from 5-6.30 to hear the Young Critics critical responses to several productions from On The Edge .

Learn about more Young Critics that are On The Edge here 

Young Critics On The Edge  is a collaboration between Barnstorm Theatre Company,NAYD (National Association for Youth Drama) Ireland and Mess Up The Mess, Get the Chance (Wales) in conjunction with the Symposium strand of the ASSITEJ Artistic Gathering for 2016.